Propane vs Electric Water Heater: Which is Better for Your Home?

If you are looking for a detailed comparison of Propane vs Electric Water Heaters, then this piece of information is for you.

Water heating is a process of using energy to heat water above its initial temperature. The most common type of water heater is a tankless water heater, which uses electricity to heat water. However, there are also other types of water heaters, such as propane water heaters and electric water heaters. Tankless water heaters are the most efficient type of water heater, as they only use electricity to heat water when it is needed.

I will try my level best to provide you with in-depth information about your query.

Propane vs. Electric Water Heaters

When it comes to comparison, there are many factors to be considered. In the following all points have been covered so that you may pick a right product for your home.

1. Energy Efficiency

Propane and electric water heaters are both energy-efficient options for heating water in your home.

  • When it comes to energy efficiency, electric water heaters are typically more efficient than gas water heaters.
  • Gas water heaters require a lot of energy to heat up the water, while electric water heaters use less energy.
  • Propane tankless water heaters are even more efficient, using 50 percent less energy than traditional tankless water heaters.

2. Gas or Electric Water Heaters: Which Heats Up Faster?

Electric water heaters typically heat water faster than their gas-powered counterparts. This is because electric models rely on heating elements to generate heat, while gas models use a pilot light to ignite a burner.

However, propane tankless water heaters typically heat water the fastest of all, since they don’t need to store hot water like tankless and tankless water heaters.

3. Lifespan of Electric Water Heater Vs Propane Heaters

The lifespan of a propane water heater and electric heater can vary depending on several factors.

  • On average, electric water heaters last about 10 years
  • Gas water heaters can last up to 20 years. This is due to the fact that gas water heaters have more moving parts than electric water heaters, which can lead to more wear and tear over time. Additionally, gas water heaters require annual maintenance in order to keep them running properly, while electric water heaters do not.

4. How Easy Is It to Install an Electric Water Heater vs Gas?

Installation of an Electric Water Heater vs Gas
  • It is typically much easier to install an electric water heater than a gas water heater. With an electric water heater, all you need to do is connect the unit to an electrical power source and supply lines for water input and output.
  • Gas water heaters require more complex installation, as you must also install a venting system for the unit.

5. Gas vs Electric Water Heater Upfront Cost

Electric water heaters are less expensive to purchase than propane or gas water heaters.

6. Propane vs electric water heater operating cost

Propane vs electric water heater operating cost can be a tricky question to answer. Both types of heaters have their own set of pros and cons when it comes to operating costs.

  • Electric water heaters tend to be less expensive to operate than propane heaters, but they also have a higher initial purchase price.
  • Propane heaters, on the other hand, have lower initial purchase prices but may be more expensive to operate over time due to the cost of propane.

7. The Pros and Cons of Propane

Gas Water Heater With Tank

Before making the switch to propane, there are a few things you should keep in mind. If you have an electric water heater, you’ll need to consider replacing it. Additionally, make sure that your propane supplier can provide you with a reliable and consistent supply of propane.

  • Faster: A gas water heater can be a good choice for some homes as it can heat water more quickly than an electric model.
  • Cost Effective: it may have a lower operating cost.
  • Propane water heaters have a shorter recovery time, meaning they can heat up water faster than electric models.
  • Propane water heaters are less likely to experience power outages than electric models.
  • Shorter lifespan: Gas models typically have a shorter lifespan than electric heaters.
  • Space: It required more space to install tank, however, tankless models are becoming increasingly popular as they do not require a storage tank, saving space.
  • Propane water heaters emit carbon monoxide gas, so it is important to have a CO detector in your home if you choose this type of heater.

8. The Pros and Cons of Electric Water Heater

There are many pros and cons to having an electric water heater.

  • Electric water heater are very efficient in how they heat water.
  • Much smaller in size than gas heaters, so they take up less space.
  • Longer lifespan than gas heaters.
  • They don’t require a vent
  • Electric water heaters are easier to install than propane models.
  • An electric water heater is that they take longer to heat up than gas water heaters.
  • Electric water heaters is that they can be more expensive to operate than gas heaters.

4 Factors to be considered before top picks of Electric Water Heaters

There are a few factors to consider when purchasing an electric water heater.

  1. The first and most important factor is the size of the unit. The size of the unit will determine how much hot water can be produced at one time.
  2. The next factor to consider is the type of unit. There are two types of electric water heaters, storage and tankless. Storage units are less expensive, but they require a larger initial investment. Tankless units are more expensive, but they offer a continuous supply of hot water.
  3. The next factor to consider is the warranty. Most electric water heaters come with a one-year warranty, but some manufacturers offer longer warranties.
  4. The last factor to consider is the price. Electric water heaters range in price from $200 to $2000.

[table id=7 /]

Best 5 Propane or Gas water heater to be considered

There are a few different types of propane and gas water heaters, but the most popular ones are the tankless, whole-house, and point-of-use models.

  • Tankless water heaters are the most efficient type, as they only heat water when you need it and don’t waste energy keeping a tank of water hot.
  • Whole-house models are ideal for homes with multiple bathrooms, as they can provide enough hot water for everyone to use at once.
  • Point-of-use models are perfect for small apartments or homes where space is limited, as they can be installed right under your sink.

[table id=8 /]


As you have read, there are pros and cons to both propane and electric water heaters. For example, a propane water heater is typically less expensive than an electric one, but you have to have a propane tank, which can be an added expense. Tankless water heaters are much more efficient than either propane or electric water heaters, so if you’re looking for the most energy-efficient option, tankless is the way to go. However, tankless water heaters can be pricier up front. If you’re looking for a more affordable option, propane or electric may be the way to go. It is your choice.

For your convince, i have suggest you some top picks of gas and electric water heaters. Don’t forget to write your feedback in comment section.

Editor Choice

5 Things to Consider Before Buying a Mini Propane Heater

Common Issues with a Propane Tank Top Heater with an Igniter!


Natural gas vs electric water heater cost?

When it comes to water heaters, there are two main types: electric and natural gas. Both have their pros and cons, but which one is more cost-effective?

Natural gas is cheaper than electricity, so it’s the more affordable option. However, electric water heaters are more energy-efficient, so they’ll save you money in the long run.

Propane vs electric water heater operating cost?

Electric water heaters are less expensive to operate than propane water heaters. The average cost of electricity is about $0.12 per kilowatt-hour (kWh), while the average cost of propane is about $0.50 per gallon.

A propane water heater with a 40-gallon tank will use about 80 gallons of propane per year, while an electric water heater will use about 940 kWh of electricity per year. The operating cost of a propane water heater is about six times higher than the operating cost of an electric water heater.

Is propane or electric water heater cheaper?

In general, electric water heaters are cheaper to operate than propane water heaters. However, propane models may be less expensive to purchase initially.

Tankless propane vs electric water heater?

The debate between tankless propane and electric water heaters is one that has been around for many years. There are pros and cons to both types of water heaters, and it really depends on your specific needs as to which one is the better choice for you.

Tankless propane water heaters are more expensive up front, but they are more energy efficient than electric water heaters and will save you money in the long run. Electric water heaters are less expensive up front but can be more expensive to operate over time.

Leave a Comment